[ Cisco thinks to himself that Finn has a really nice smile; he's glad to see it, wants to encourage Finn to keep talking about this, since it's clearly and fond memory and one that makes him happy. So he lets himself be just as bright and excited as he can be, prompting: ]

Okay, but like, now you know you gotta tell me the rest. You can't just say 'oh yeah she hit me in the face with a giant stick the first time we met' and not give a dude the full scoop.

[ And Cisco even perches himself on the arm of the sofa, looking at Finn expectantly, as if he's settling in for quite the tale. ]